I need to talk to you about pie. Specifically, the kind of pie that makes your whole holiday table feel extra special and just a little bit magical. I've rounded up 24 ridiculously good Christmas pies that cover everything from cozy classics to totally dreamy no bake numbers. Trust me, one of these is about to become your new favorite tradition.

1. Best Black Forest Pie

This is the dreamiest, most decadent black forest cake you will ever meet in pie form. I thought the cake could not get any better, and then I tried this. It is built with fudgy chocolate, sweet cherries, and fluffy whipped cream all wrapped up in a flaky crust. My self control went right out the window.

Go to Recipe →

2. Snickerdoodle Pie

Snickerdoodle pie is just as fun to eat as it is to say out loud. Is it a cookie, a cake, or a pie? Honestly, who cares. All you need to know is that it tastes outrageously delicious. A super soft buttery snickerdoodle gets topped with sweet syrup, cinnamon, and a cream cheese glaze. It is Christmas in pie form!

Go to Recipe →

3. Treacle Tart

Does treacle tart ring a bell? If you've spent any time with a certain boy wizard, you'll know it's his absolute favorite. This is a traditional British treat made with a buttery shortbread crust and a lovely lemon scented filling. The inside is a simple mix of lemon zest, breadcrumbs, and treacle. So wonderfully cozy.

Go to Recipe →

4. Coffee Pie

All your favorite coffee flavors get tucked into this smooth and creamy pie. It is a truly lovely way to kick off the day, if you ask me. Rich, creamy, and full of just the right coffee flavor, it tastes amazing and smells like heaven. A rich buttery crust pairs perfectly with that silky filling.

Go to Recipe →

5. Salted Caramel Pie

Sweet and salty together is just one of those combos that always wins. Want your dessert to completely steal the show? Pour some salted caramel over it. That is my foolproof move and it never lets me down. This pie is all the proof you need.

Go to Recipe →

6. Turtle Pie

Turtle pie is a timeless dessert loaded with incredible flavors and amazing textures. One slice is never enough, trust me. It has a buttery graham cracker crust and a creamy filling all topped with pecans, chocolate sauce, and caramel. Every single bite is pure sinful delight.

Go to Recipe →

7. Dutch Pear & Nutmeg Pie

Sweet, juicy pears seasoned just right get baked into a fresh pie. Just thinking about eating a slice while curled up by the fire makes me so happy. Dutch pears and nutmeg together create the coziest, warmest flavors for the season.

Go to Recipe →

8. Lemon Meringue Pie

Sweet, tangy, velvety custard sits in a crisp buttery crust under mounds of fluffy meringue. Lemon meringue pie is a Christmas classic that always hits the spot. It is perfectly sweet, gently tangy, and so refreshing. That bright yellow filling is honestly like eating a slice of sunshine.

Go to Recipe →

9. Rocky Road Pie

If rocky road is your go to ice cream flavor, you are going to fall hard for this pie. Cocoa powder, cream cheese, and melted chocolate blend into a super smooth, rich, and decadent filling. The graham cracker crust adds that crisp buttery crunch against all that chocolate goodness.

Go to Recipe →

10. Cranberry Pear Pie

Juicy sweet pears and bright tart cranberries come together in this irresistible fruity pie. There is just something magical about that sweet and tangy combo. It is the ultimate refreshing flavor. That is why these two fruits work together so beautifully.

Go to Recipe →

11. Hazelnut Pie

This one goes out to all my fellow Nutella fans. Cream cheese and Nutella swirl together into one wildly rich, creamy, and nutty pie. The hazelnut and cream cheese combo is seriously bold and mind blowing. And the best part? No oven needed for this one. Hooray for easy recipes!

Go to Recipe →

12. Cranberry Orange Custard Pie

This fruity pie brings together the goodness of cranberries and oranges in the most refreshing way. It is guaranteed to put a big smile on your face. A buttery crust holds a sweet and tangy custard, and the orange zest plus cranberries make it extra bright. That gorgeous red hue is just perfect for the holidays.

Go to Recipe →

13. Candy Cane Pie

Candy canes are basically the official candy of Christmas, so putting them in a pie just feels right. This peppermint beauty is an absolute crowd pleaser and so hard to resist. It starts with an Oreo crust, gets a sweet cream cheese filling, and finishes with a sprinkle of crushed peppermint on top.

Go to Recipe →

14. Chocolate Brownie Pie

Cannot decide between brownies and pie? Who says you have to choose. Brownies are pretty amazing all on their own. But this chocolate brownie pie is a whole other level of heaven sent. By mashing up two beloved classics, you get a certified hit.

Go to Recipe →

15. Buckeye Pie

Chocolate plus peanut butter? That is what I call a match made in heaven. I suggest making at least two of these because the first one is going to vanish fast. Rich chocolate with that sweet and salty peanut butter is just plain irresistible.

Go to Recipe →

16. Mincemeat Pie

This one comes all the way from across the pond and it is pure holiday comfort. It's a classic British bake with a buttery, flaky crust wrapped around a warm mix of dried fruits and spices. It bakes up golden and gorgeous every single time. Honestly, I would happily eat this pie in the middle of July.

Go to Recipe →

17. Pecan Pie

Stop looking, because this is the one. My goodness, is this pecan pie a total winner. You get that crisp crust, a wonderfully gooey center, and those toasty pecans on top. What gets me is how a humble little mix of sugar, salt, cinnamon, and vanilla turns into something so complex and perfect with the nuts.

Go to Recipe →

18. Eggnog Pie

If you love eggnog, you simply have to try this pie. Christmas just doesn't feel complete without that familiar flavor, but why not shake things up a little? This recipe takes the classic holiday drink and transforms it into a lip smacking, totally jaw dropping dessert.

Go to Recipe →

19. Plum Pie

Sweet red plums get a lovely hit of cinnamon in this crisp and buttery pie. It is a beautifully simple recipe that gives you stunning results. The cinnamon, sugar, and plums all come together in perfect harmony. That rich crust is the perfect base for the syrupy fruit filling.

Go to Recipe →

20. Macadamia Coconut Tart

Imagine your favorite pecan pie got whisked away on a tropical vacation. This macadamia coconut tart is insanely rich, super buttery, and completely addictive. One little bite and you are basically on a beach somewhere sunny. If macadamia nuts and coconut have never met on your plate, now is absolutely the time.

Go to Recipe →

21. Dulce de Leche Pie

Rich cream cheese and an ooey gooey dulce de leche are nestled into a buttery Oreo crust. I must have died and gone straight to dessert heaven. Thick caramel and cream cheese make the most beautifully balanced filling. It is sweet but not too sweet, with just a tiny hint of tang. Simple, and it completely hits the spot.

Go to Recipe →

22. Coconut Macaroon Pie

Bring a little tropical flair to your holiday spread with this decadent number. Coconut macaroons are already rich, buttery bites full of shredded coconut goodness. Now picture all of that incredible flavor baked right into a pie. That is exactly what this dessert delivers.

Go to Recipe →

23. German Chocolate Pie

Calling all chocolate people. This pie is your dream come true. Picture a German chocolate brownie and a classic chocolate pie coming together as one glorious dessert. That chewy, gooey filling gets loaded with toasted pecans and plenty of chocolate inside a golden crust. I honestly couldn't want anything more.

Go to Recipe →

24. Rum Raisin Apple Pie

This one simple addition turns a classic apple pie into a classy, boozy, heavenly treat. The spiked raisins give every bite such a lovely contrast of texture and flavor. You get crisp, chewy, sweet, and a whisper of bitter all at once. Sounds like absolute perfection to me.

Go to Recipe →