I have a little secret for you. Thanksgiving dessert doesn't have to be the same old pumpkin and pecan routine, and it definitely doesn't have to be fussy. I've gathered 13 ridiculously good pies and tarts that are simple enough to actually pull off during the holiday chaos. From silky custards to no-bake wonders, there's something here that will make your table feel extra special.

1. No-Bake Butterscotch Pie

Okay, this one is truly dangerous. You get a Biscoff cookie crust, a luscious no-bake butterscotch filling, and then brown sugar cinnamon whipped cream piled on top. One slice is never ever enough, especially once that dreamy toffee drizzle hits the scene. Since it never sees the oven, it also saves you precious space for the turkey and sides. Total win win, right?

Go to Recipe →

2. No-Bake German Chocolate Pie

German chocolate cake is known for being moist and dark with that one of a kind coconut and pecan topping, and this pie captures all of that. The luxurious ganache filling and the nutty top make it beyond decadent. Put some whipped cream on the plate and watch your guests go completely wild for it.

Go to Recipe →

3. Apple Cheddar Pie

Hear me out. Apple and cheddar just works, it really does, and you should totally give it a try. I am not talking about just throwing a giant block of cheese into the apple filling, I promise. Instead, the cheese is baked right into the crust with just a little extra tucked in with the apples.

Go to Recipe →

4. Spiced Plum Pie

The color of this pie alone makes it worthy of a spot on your holiday table. It happens to be vegan, which is a pretty great bonus. Plum might not be the first thing you think of for Thanksgiving, but nobody will be able to resist a slice. I like it best served warm with a scoop of ice cream, though if you let it cool, it gets wonderfully jammy.

Go to Recipe →

5. Honey Pie

This pie takes a creamy custard and flavors it with honey for something wonderfully different but equally delicious. Custard pies are simple, smooth, and incredibly moreish. I love that this recipe uses honey to make it feel a little out of the box. I have a feeling you are going to love it too.

Go to Recipe →

6. Cranberry Orange Custard Pie

As much as I adore the old favorites like apple and pecan, I really love setting out something a little different. This pie is bursting with fresh, tart cranberries and a silky-smooth orange custard that mellows out all that sourness. The custard bakes right inside the shell, so you don't even have to bother with blind-baking the crust. It makes holiday dessert feel fresh again.

Go to Recipe →

7. Toffee Almond Pie

Pecan pie is always a hit during the holidays with that crunchy top and gooey center. This pie has all of those exact same textures and a very similar filling. The big difference is that it uses almonds. Unlike pecans, which have a substantial crunch, the sliced almonds give you a wonderfully crisp texture in every single bite.

Go to Recipe →

8. Pear and Almond Tart

This might just be the prettiest Thanksgiving pie recipe you will ever make. The almond frangipane paired with the pears is incredible, and that apricot glaze makes the whole thing look like it came from a bakery window. It may not be a classic, but I have a feeling it is going to become a family favorite the moment you serve it.

Go to Recipe →

9. Gingersnap Cranberry Lime Pie

This one is definitely not your typical Thanksgiving pie, but it absolutely should be. It is filled with bright flavor and it looks stunning on the table. The crust is a simple mix of gingersnaps, walnuts, butter, and brown sugar that you just press right into the pie dish. You don't even need to roll it out, just bake it for a quick 12 to 15 minutes.

Go to Recipe →

10. Butternut Squash Pie

Swapping butternut squash for pumpkin, or even using a little of both, is a fun little twist as the holidays roll in. The taste is awfully close to what you know and love, but butternut squash tends to be easier to find. It bakes up into a really yummy Thanksgiving pie. I love serving a slice with a fluffy cloud of whipped cream or a scoop of ice cream melting right on top.

Go to Recipe →

11. Salted Caramel Pumpkin Pie

You already know how I feel about salted caramel, and when it meets up with my favorite fall pumpkin, I am absolutely there. This recipe gives you a smooth, perfectly spiced pumpkin pie with a surprising twist. The salted caramel gets mixed right into the filling itself. Every single bite is sweet, salty, and so, so good.

Go to Recipe →

12. Cinnamon Pie

This pie is basically a cinnamon-spiced cheesecake, and it is not playing around. It is creamy, sweet, and absolutely loaded with cinnamon flavor. You know that incredible scent that hits you when you walk into a craft store during the winter? Imagine someone bottled that up and baked it into a pie. That is exactly what this is.

Go to Recipe →

13. Lemon Meringue Pie

You might not think of lemon meringue as a classic Thanksgiving dessert, but I think it is kind of perfect. After a heavy meal full of rich foods, this pie feels wonderfully light and zippy. This version has a creamy cheesecake layer hiding under plenty of gooey meringue on top. Honestly, every bite is better than the last.

Go to Recipe →