Most people think of tiramisu or cannoli when they imagine Italian desserts, but an Italian Christmas table is a whole different kind of magic. I’m talking golden domes of sweet bread, honey-drenched fried dough, and cookies that taste like citrus and spice. Here are 17 traditional Italian Christmas desserts that deserve a spot on your holiday table this year.

1. Homemade Italian Cream Cake

If you need a homemade cake that’s fluffy and moist, this Italian cream cake is calling your name. The buttermilk makes these the lightest, moistest cakes you can imagine, even with crunchy chopped pecans in the batter. The four-ingredient frosting is rich, creamy, and made with butter, cream cheese, vanilla extract, and powdered sugar.

Go to Recipe →

2. Ricciarelli (Italian Almond Cookies)

If you’ve had Italian wedding cookies, then you already know the general idea. They share many of the same ingredients, like almonds, vanilla extract, and powdered sugar. Ricciarelli, though, are soft and chewy instead of crunchy, and they include lemon juice and orange zest for a bright pop of flavor.

Go to Recipe →

3. Tiramisu Semifreddo

This frozen dessert takes everything you love about tiramisu and gives it a fun little twist. Basically, it’s tiramisu with ice cream and a fourth cup of brandy added for good measure. If you’re already a fan of the classic, this one is just as tasty and even more decadent.

Go to Recipe →

4. Mini Chocolate Panettone

These cute little panettones are just the right size for one happy person. You still get that same lovely taste and texture, only in miniature form. They’re also loaded with yummy chocolate chips for extra sweetness.

Go to Recipe →

5. 5-Ingredient Cannolis

Five-ingredient cannolis bring you wonderfully crunchy shells and a sweet, tangy filling made from ricotta, confectioner’s sugar, chocolate chips, and vanilla extract. Want a brighter, zestier bite? Toss in a little orange zest too.

Go to Recipe →

6. Italian Panettone

This one sits somewhere between a gorgeous cake and a giant loaf of sweet yeast bread. The icing sugar, vanilla, and rum keep things beautifully sweet, while the orange and lemon zests, raisins, and candied citrus peels bring that tangy bite you can’t stop going back for.

Go to Recipe →

7. Authentic Italian Struffoli Recipe

These golden-brown balls are pure crunchy honey joy. Each one is a sticky, deep-fried little bite of heaven topped with honey, candied sprinkles, and anything else you love. The whole thing comes together in just 35 minutes, and you shape it in a fun way so it looks as pretty as it tastes.

Go to Recipe →

8. Pandoro Christmas Tree Cake

This Christmas tree-shaped cake has a similar taste to panettone, but it’s softer, fluffier, and shaped in a lovelier way. You can absolutely make your own homemade pandoro. A store-bought one works beautifully too if you slice it up for this delightful dessert.

Go to Recipe →

9. Zeppole, Italian Ricotta Doughnuts

You can whip up over a dozen of these deep-fried balls of deliciousness in less than an hour. They have crisp, sweet outsides and a sweet, tangy ricotta cheese filling. That powdered sugar dusting on top makes them even tastier, and the whole thing is a light, airy treat everyone will love.

Go to Recipe →

10. Panna Cotta

For something so simple to make, panna cotta is a stunning and elegant dessert that works for Christmas, wedding receptions, or your fanciest dinner parties. You make it with unflavored gelatin, heavy cream, sugar, vanilla extract, and milk or cold water. It needs a few hours to set into that creamy, Jell-O-like texture it’s famous for.

Go to Recipe →

11. Authentic Italian Tiramisu

This six-ingredient tiramisu is the real deal, exactly how it was always meant to be enjoyed. You only need eggs, powdered sugar, mascarpone, ladyfingers, espresso, and cocoa powder to pull it together. The rich chocolate and coffee flavor plus that creamy filling against the crunch of ladyfingers is simply divine.

Go to Recipe →

12. Homemade Torrone Italian Nut Nougat

This nougat bar is soft, sweet, and chewy, and the nuts give it a touch of saltiness and crunch too. Just remember that a little bit goes a long way here. It is super sweet, so don’t overdo it, and honestly, a hot cup of coffee or tea alongside is perfect.

Go to Recipe →

13. Panettone Bombe (Christmas Ice Cream Cake)

This striking dome-shaped cake takes only 15 minutes to prep but needs 8 hours to chill, so don’t leave it for the last minute. It puts a lovely Italian spin on the classic ice cream cake. I love topping mine with dark chocolate like the recipe suggests, but any chocolate works beautifully, and you can get a lot fancier than plain sprinkles.

Go to Recipe →

14. Italian Chocolate Toto Cookies

They might look like simple chocolate cookies with sprinkles, but there’s so much more going on here. Each bite gives you hints of orange, vanilla, cloves, cinnamon, nuts, and even a little pepper. Small cookies, huge flavor, and I am here for it.

Go to Recipe →

15. Pizzelle Della Nonna

These crispy, wafer-thin cookies look like fancy little waffles and taste like whatever you decide to flavor them with. Go with vanilla extract, anise, chocolate, almond extract, or something else entirely. They’re wonderfully crunchy and always a hit during the holidays.

Go to Recipe →

16. Mostaccioli Di Mamma

These chocolatey cookies are nutty, slightly spiced, and have a honey and chocolate flavor that is completely out of this world. The trick is not to bake them too long. The texture should stay soft with a little give, and if you over-bake them they get hard and crispy, which is still tasty but not quite what you want here.

Go to Recipe →

17. Italian Cookies

Biting into one of these super-soft cookies is like biting into a cloud, a sweet, nutty, sugar and sprinkle covered cloud. The glaze is creamy and completely delicious, and you can change up the sprinkle colors to match whatever holiday you’re celebrating.

Go to Recipe →